• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
The Association for Surgical Education

The Association for Surgical Education

Impacting Surgical Education Globally

  • About
    • By-Laws
    • Contact the ASE
    • Leadership
    • Past Presidents
    • Standing Committees
    • Global Surgical Education-Journal of the ASE
    • ASE Strategic Plan 2023-2026
  • Join!
  • Meeting
    • Annual Meeting Information
    • ASE Fall Meeting & Courses
    • Call For Abstracts
      • Scientific Sessions
      • Candlelight Session
      • ASE Pre-Meeting Course Proposal
      • Shark Tank: Multi-Institutional Research Submissions
      • Thinking Out of the Box
      • Workshop and Panel Submissions
    • Exhibits
    • Commercial Promotional Opportunities
    • Institutional Members & Sponsors
    • Meetings Archives
    • Media Gallery
  • Awards
    • ASE/APDS: Collaborative Grant Initiative
    • ASE DEI Underrepresented in Medicine (URiM) Scholarship Application
    • Education Awards
    • Shark Tank: Multi-Institutional Research Grant
  • Programs
    • 2025-2026 Association for Surgical Education Curriculum in Education Innovation and Teaching (ASCENT)
    • Academy of Clerkship Directors
    • Academic Program Administrator Certification in Surgery
    • Ethics of Surgery Fellowship (EthoS)
    • Surgeon Empowerment Leadership Fellowship (SELF 2.0)
    • Surgical Education Research Fellowship (SERF)
      • Surgical Education Research Fellowship Graduates
  • Foundation
    • Donate Now!
    • Foundation Board
    • The ASE Foundation: Building for the Future – Donors
    • Deb DaRosa Scholarship Application
    • Dr. Debra DaRosa Career Development Scholarship – Donors
    • Patricia Numann, MD, FACS, Scholarship for LMIC Surgical Educators
    • CESERT Pyramid Grant Application
    • Spotlight on CESERT Pyramid Grant Awardees!
    • Newsletter
    • Annual Report
    • Review Committee
    • Grants Awarded
    • Corporate Partners
  • Resources
    • Policy for Conducting Survey Research of ASE Members
    • Surgical Education Research Webinar Series
    • Podcasts
    • ASE CoSEF Peer Engagement for Education Research Success Webinar Series
  • ATLAS
  • Donate
  • Login

Session Design Submission Review

← Go back

The Experts Weigh In: Asking for a "Good" Letter of Recommendation

Session TypePanel

Vihas Patel MD
Email hidden; Javascript is required.
The Experts Weigh In: Asking for a "Good" Letter of Recommendation
Is this submission from an ASE Committee, Task Force, or Working Group?

Yes

Which Committee(s)/Task Force(s)/Working Group(s)?
  • Faculty Development
  • Membership
Session Information

Session Description

In academia, the well-crafted Letter of Recommendation (LOR) is not merely a formality; it can be a critical determinant of a candidate’s promotion, tenure and funding. Given the import of good LORs, it is imperative for the candidate to advocate for themself effectively. This panel of departmental and MedEd leaders will share their perspectives on best practices and avoidable pitfalls when requesting a LOR.  The expert panel will also share advice for compelling content, highlighting what makes a good letter.  Finally, the learner will be introduced to a new Society member benefit aimed to help juniors increase their professional network, “The Letter Writers Repository.”

Advice will be tiered to the medical student, resident and faculty with a special focus on differentiating requests for promotion versus funding, as in grant applications.  This session will focus on how to truly advocate, both from the vantage of the candidate and from the vantage of the letter writer. It’s about transforming a competent applicant into a truly compelling applicant. The panelists will discuss how the LOR process helps to strategically position a candidate’s experiences to align with the specific values and requirements of target position, professional society or funding request by moving beyond generic praise to powerful, personalized endorsements.

Tools, Skills, and Information Surgical Educators Will Take Back:

Participants will gain a deeper understanding of the critical elements that make an LOR impactful, and what information to provide the letter writer to ensure a tailored letter.

Ultimately, this session aims to empower surgical educators at all levels of career stage and proficiency to advocate for themselves for compelling letters of recommendations that are not just strong, but also strategically powerful. This directly benefits our Society by enhancing our members’ laurels and influence.

Course Objective 1

1. The learner will understand the “how” of requesting a good LOR including whom to approach, how to reach out to them, and what information to provide them

Course Objective 2

2. The learner who is requesting the LOR will know what information to present to the letter writer

Course Objective 3

3. The learner will be able to differentiate LOR content needed for promotion versus grant support

Session Outline
Activity Order Title of Presentation or Activity Presenter/Faculty Name Presenter/Faculty Email Time allotted in minutes for activity

1

The Experts Weigh In: Asking for a "Good" Letter of Recommendation – Introduction (background and panelists)

Jacob Peschman

jpeschma@mcw.edu

10

2

Moderated Questions for Panelists

Rani Schuchert

schuchertv@upmc.edu

30

3

Q&A

Jacob Peschman

jpeschma@mcw.edu

15

4

Instructions for Use of the ASE Letter Writers' Respository (with Kim Hendershot)

Vihas Patel

vpatel13@northwell.edu

5